Who fears the queer Arab?

Show notes

“I hear that the aerial bombing of Berlin Neukölln is imminent. Can this be true?”

Since October 7th, Berlin’s Arab diaspora has faced a surge of violence and persecution. Life in Berlin has become dangerous, because regardless of personal history or individual perspective, they’re caught between Staatsräson, German memory culture, and accusations of imported antisemitism that have led to public backlash and humiliating legal attacks.

In a new book, Fear Eats Ali, curator and writer Edwin Nasr captures that reality in a work of what he calls hysterical fiction. Through the character of Ali - a queer new transplant in Berlin from Beirut navigating his own political ambivalence and family history - Nasr explores the surreal and painful reality of navigating the German legal system and life in the city.

In this episode, Nasr talks with HEIST founding editor Peter Matthews about the origin of the book and the idea of hysterical fiction; his own legal fight; sexual politics; and the overlapping histories of trauma shared by Berlin and Beirut.

Links & Resources:

Music and sound by Patrick Nininger.

Show transcript

00:00:00: you know, people who were once colleagues with whom I was breaking bread.

00:00:04: Who suddenly didn't want anything to do with a lot of us?

00:00:07: Who are snitching... Who?

00:00:09: we're ensuring that you wouldn't get any jobs even outside Germany sending emails or institutions collaborating with this and that it just became an untenable situation And people showed their true colors in ways still shock me.

00:00:22: honestly

00:00:29: Welcome To The Heist Podcast!

00:00:30: I'm Ben Schumann Stoller.

00:00:32: I am going read A Little Excerpt from a book that we talk about in this episode, and it's a dream sequence.

00:00:38: And someone is talking to an officer.

00:00:40: he says I hear the aerial bombing of Berlin-Neukölln as imminent can't be true?

00:00:47: And then officers say okay listen up there isn't present gross demographic disproportion in favor of Arabs afflicting Neuköllne.

00:00:55: one need not security expert identify this major problem The symptoms Islamist poison having already revealed themselves.

00:01:04: There's also the problem of The Street Of Zonanale, in particular.

00:01:08: Where almost fifty years ago the Arabs first arrived from Beirut, Ramallah and Damascus And Also From the Camps of Shatilla In Yarmouk.

00:01:16: Their arrival remains to this day an enigma To us.

00:01:19: these Arabs neither landed at the Tegel Airport nor At the train stations Which is to say that there was no record of their arrival having ever been officially registered.

00:01:28: A more appropriate way to describe their appearance would be to Say they slipped through a loophole both real and metaphorical, one that stretches the laws of physics and gravity itself.

00:01:40: So this is an excerpt from a novel – A Piece Of Fiction From A Brand New Book That Was Just Published A Couple Weeks Ago.

00:01:44: The book's called Fear Eats Ali.

00:01:46: The titles are not in a fastbender film.

00:01:48: maybe you've seen This episode has conversation with author Edwin Nasser With Heist's Own Peter Matthews.

00:01:58: He wrote this book as he explained to Peter partially to capture what it felt like to live in Berlin, as an Arab.

00:02:04: As a homosexual Arab after October seventh.

00:02:06: I won't give away too many spoilers.

00:02:08: the book involves A case of assaulting a police officer Someone accused of that anyway and court case and happens After It.

00:02:16: And yeah Edwin calls The Book a piece of hysterical fiction Which is interesting term.

00:02:21: Him & Peter talk about What That Means?

00:02:23: The book itself definitely captures modern berlin Life on Zonale, it talks about overlapping conflicting political movements.

00:02:33: It talks about history memory east and west .It talks about cancel culture ,it talks about the violence The paranoia that much of the Arab diaspora went through here after October seventh And Edwin himself went through legal issues That were humiliating...and he talked to Peter about that.

00:02:49: But anyway..that's enough for me.

00:02:51: Here is Peter Matthews & Edwin Nasser.

00:02:54: Today, we're with Edwin Nasser the author of Fear Eats Ali a novel modern Berlin which tracks some of the issues We've been writing about since we started Heist and I'm very pleased to welcome you Edwin.

00:03:09: And yes One of the reasons i like this book is that there's been A few berlin novels?

00:03:15: I think Which sort of make The city a place as a Sort Of escape from politics.

00:03:20: You know it's a sort of play politics happens somewhere else and this book really brings politics back in.

00:03:27: And yes, I wonder... So thanks very much for coming!

00:03:30: Can you just tell us how the book came about?

00:03:33: Thank you so much for having me.

00:03:36: Originally, this book was not supposed to be a book of fiction.

00:03:39: I was commissioned by Wichlischkeid books to write long essay for series that has yet come titled Migrating Marxisms About The Relationship Between Hezbollah and the left in Lebanon following the collapse of The Soviet Union.

00:03:57: And then October seven happened, I felt quite stuck for a year... ...and thought that whatever I'd be writing would end up feeling quite outdated by the time its release.

00:04:09: Also i did not necessarily feel very at ease writing objectively about Hezballah In A Place Like Germany Because Of The Nature Of The Discourse How Irrational It's Been.

00:04:24: And so in a sense, I proposed to my publisher on us at the time quite at last minute whether i could shift towards fiction and was given quiet tight deadline.

00:04:35: To do so.

00:04:37: it flowed very organically.

00:04:38: but what is really wanting with that book?

00:04:43: sort of mirror general sense suspicion paranoia gripping city my own fears and anxieties, those of a lot people I was in conversation with from the diasporic Arab community.

00:04:59: And i also wanted to play on those contradictions In terms of what Berlin represented because... A lot of us are here Because it did feel like I wouldn't say safe haven but kind of escape From What we've been accustomed too in our respective localities.

00:05:15: All that shifted quite violently after October seven.

00:05:20: Yeah, definitely.

00:05:21: I mean...I think that lots of people have had that experience Of politics kind-of coming crashing in whether you wanted it to or not.

00:05:30: And i thought your book did a really good job In bringing the atmosphere and You call actually work of hysterical fiction.

00:05:39: I wondered if could do two things.

00:05:42: Can tell us about what?

00:05:44: I don't know how much spoilers Or not give away but Can you tell us just a bit about what actually happens in the book as much to kind of set it up, but then also yeah.

00:05:53: Tell us about this idea for you?

00:05:55: What's this idea of hysteria?

00:05:57: uh...in the

00:05:58: book?".

00:05:58: So I called that work on hysterical fiction As i said To also mirror The fact That I found the discourse coming emanating from Germany In the aftermath Of October seven to be itself very hysterical.

00:06:10: um and so..I really wanted to maintain A certain register that could in a sense, catch up on everything that was happening internally as we were following these events unfolding in real time somehow.

00:06:31: It's the difference between I would say work of general fiction and work of hysterical fiction would be that you know historical fiction would come when... You'd want to lay out certain truths but also want to push them to a certain extreme so that they become half-lies, not entire lies in a sense.

00:06:51: What do you mean by that?

00:06:51: Well I think for example having to experience the discourse in Germany prop itself up and just throw yourself at your face does play around with your head a little bit.

00:07:06: it does give you a bizarre sense of what is real and I really wanted to hone in on

00:07:25: that.

00:07:47: There's a narrative device that has become a bit of cliché within literature.

00:07:50: That is the unreliable narrator, but I do think this particular cliche bodes itself very well to how things unfolded in Germany and i couldn't have thought about different approach for work through that novel than by adopting it... ...I don't think that the unrelyable narrator here is in service of a narrative-driven plot, I think it's more to me an exploration of psyche at the time of fear and paranoia.

00:08:15: At a time of cowardice as well and defeat.

00:08:17: And this grueling sense not knowing what to do with oneself In the face history being in motion.

00:08:26: Let's go very concretely then.

00:08:27: Can you tell us just how does the book start?

00:08:30: What happens?

00:08:31: Who's Ali?

00:08:33: So Ali Is A Thirty Something Homosexual from a southern Lebanese town who immigrated to Berlin in two thousand fifteen, sixteen I'd say at the height of so-called Syrian refugee crisis.

00:08:51: He makes sure to mark the difference between how he arrived to Germany and how Syrians did you know by saying that he just took the plane to come And there's already a sense of shame on how he managed like make it through...he wants his engineering degree and learn German, and I don't know procure himself with a not visa passport.

00:09:11: A European passport.

00:09:13: He has family in Germany from his mom's side who immigrated in the nineties And uh... His father once fought with a communist militia against the Israeli occupation In the south following the besiegement of Beirut in eighty-two.

00:09:35: because he also believes that due to his father having abandoned his comrades in the eighties, He has been somehow genetically gifted The cowardly gene and Has a very ambivalent relationship with politics at large.

00:09:53: In Lebanon was a member of the Lebanese Communist Party but here finds himself unable To care At all!

00:10:00: He is really wanting to escape and to become a full-blown homosexual, in his sense.

00:10:07: He just wants to go to Fikindai Thousand and take drugs.

00:10:12: he is very adamant about not engaging with the politics of the Arab diaspora because he also senses that everyone's coming in with a lot of baggage That it's pretty impossible to untangle And work through... I would say accidentally at a Palestine demo and is accused by a cop of assault.

00:10:37: We don't understand in the novel whether that's true or not, I mean throughout the novel.

00:10:41: Ali does say it was a lie but i'm not necessarily prone to think he even matters.

00:10:46: He could have assaulted a cop.

00:10:49: The cop can be lying.

00:10:50: Both statements are true And they matter much.

00:10:53: It also got remarkable sort of scene in that October seventh happens, you know the character experiences it and then You have this sort of change of atmosphere both kind of In that scene there's a change of Atmosphere And Then also in the book The kind Of whole political climate.

00:11:10: You Sort of experience how things Kind of I suppose the walls close in some kind of Political way.

00:11:19: How did you actually?

00:11:21: Experience That Change in Berlin?

00:11:25: I've experienced it pretty violently.

00:11:27: I mean, i brought it upon myself a little bit but you know um...I might have been too naive about the limits of speech and freedom of speech here.

00:11:36: after October seven- I moved to year end in two thousand twenty three.

00:11:40: uh..i haven't necessarily lived in Berlin for long time And had only nine months on my job as curator at an art space that was emerging in Schoenberg.

00:11:50: when I woke up on October ten to an article that a journalist from TVELT wrote about me and two, three other artists basically accusing us of anti-Semitism.

00:11:59: And also there was a particular word he used but i still find very interesting misanthropy That created the domino effect because afterwards within this span of a week or two... ...I was featured in over what might say forty articles different publications among them The Tads which was very insistent on, you know featuring me every couple of months for a year.

00:12:24: The

00:12:24: ostensibly sort of left-wing publication tax.

00:12:26: Yes and so yeah that led to that exact journalist who had like broken the news I don't know something.

00:12:35: i posted in October seven To basically assemble A two hundred page file On Me That He Sent to the Police.

00:12:43: And So I Was Then Required to Attend Court for the crime of approval of crimes, I don't know how to say that in German.

00:12:51: Like you were giving your... You are approving off them?

00:12:54: Yes.

00:12:57: Originally we lost and then we appealed and the case was dropped.

00:13:02: but in the meantime i mean..I had lost all potential gigs.

00:13:07: i was receiving very bizarre mail some death threats here and there through the scene.

00:13:15: that was...the October seventh scene in the book, I think things happened quite differently for Ali than they did for me.

00:13:24: But it's funny because-I mean, The October Seventh Scene takes place at an orgy.

00:13:29: and i wanted to take place at a orgy because orgies tend to be spaces in Berlin where you end up being with very half hazard like grouping of people on assortment of randos That are just conjoined by the need have sex.

00:13:46: It is meant to be quite a safe space, right?

00:13:50: Because everyone's on... I don't know.

00:13:51: On drugs and everyone's generous with the other And everybody feeling vulnerable.

00:13:55: Then somehow politics creeps in.

00:13:59: You realize that you have to account for who was present Who might be dangerous or not Wanting.

00:14:07: through this extreme I just wanted convey how i felt after October seven regarding cultural sector.

00:14:14: People were once colleagues with whom I was breaking bread, who suddenly didn't want anything to do with a lot of us.

00:14:22: Who were snitching... Who are ensuring that you wouldn't get any jobs even outside Germany?

00:14:29: sending emails or institutions?

00:14:31: we're collaborating with this and that it just became an untenable situation And people showed their true colors in ways still shock me today.

00:14:39: honestly

00:14:41: It's remarkable.

00:14:44: you saw it all over, that sort of... You know?

00:14:46: You saw journalists curators.

00:14:50: Lots of people were all denouncing each other and I think your book does a really good job bringing the atmosphere in.

00:15:02: A bit more about this idea of hysteria what do they mean to you exactly?

00:15:08: because there's some definition trying to obey the impossible rules of another.

00:15:16: And there does seem something a bit like that in The German Reaction, two October seventh and it's kind of... There is an idea that there IS a commitment to SOMETHING THAT HAS TO BE FOLLOWED but they've got everything the wrong way around!

00:15:34: Actually this one term I have seen used in describing German reaction, which is hysterical obedience.

00:15:41: You know they're always trying to follow a rule and then not quite sure which one to follow?

00:15:44: Is that something you sort of

00:15:46: noticed?".

00:15:47: I think it was Toby Hasslitz's term.

00:15:49: no the discussion of obedience... Maybe!

00:15:51: ...I mean i think beyond obedience.

00:15:54: what my attachment to the to the term hysteria- I mean It's quite gendered term but I think its funny when you apply it too.

00:16:02: non-gender context also because It really annoys people, it's quite a flippant term.

00:16:13: I think to me this has to do more with the irrational ways in which the German establishment not only reacted to the October seven events and what followed but also found means that were both fantastical and ahistorical to justify whatever came after in addressing the October seven events and themselves, you know.

00:16:39: The terminology that was used to describe it as a pogrom And then also what came afterwards Was even worse.

00:16:49: I'm thinking particularly about something That has been ongoing for the last two three years but A particular say op-ed by Develdt That came out last week For example.

00:17:00: It's called I am not in solidarity with Palestinians Groundbreaking news for a developed journalist.

00:17:06: And he brought in this thing where he said that, you know the reason why to him and everyone October seven is worse than The Holocaust was because Hamas did what they did with glee and did not hide it whereas the Nazis were ashamed somehow apparently of what they had done-.

00:17:28: He also say the method of killing was quick in The Concentration Council that it was sort less a crime.

00:17:36: It really, quite remarkably terrifying op-ed but you do see who's saying things and its not about what you say or where to say them and whom they seem to represent.

00:17:51: And it is worse than revisionism as a project for rehabilitation.

00:17:55: I feel like this.

00:17:57: at certain point.

00:17:58: i mentioned something on how For Ali it felt like he was quite confused about how to react to October seven because I think He was still in full denial and I wasn't too interested And also trying to understand what his position was towards October seventh.

00:18:14: I do not think this book is about that actually But he does say something to the tune of That God had gifted this moment to the Germans, Because somehow they could now free themselves of the burden, thinking that they've committed the most wrong towards the Jews and not found an entity.

00:18:33: That they can throw all their projections and fantasies upon and sort-of erect as the new Nazis in a sense?

00:18:42: Yeah exactly I mean it's that idea i suppose of imported antisemitism.

00:18:47: you know trying to imagine that Muslims fled the Syria and so on, were responsible for bringing anti-Semitism to Germany as if it had not existed here before.

00:19:00: I wonder if you could talk about... You yourself did go to court and went through a kind of legal system which is not at all the same.

00:19:08: i understand what Ali goes though but there how was your own experience with dealing with that German legal system?

00:19:14: I mean..I think the worst thing would have happened didn't happen.

00:19:20: I do think it was an extremely humiliating experience to be honest.

00:19:23: It's quite surreal also, being in court and having to perform atonement and shame on the face of you know... An extremely righteous judge and public prosecutor who are looking me like i'm some kind of vermin.

00:19:38: I like

00:19:38: all the court scenes from this book.

00:19:40: they're very funny!

00:19:43: Yeah..it is a really humiliating experience because we were a year and half, two years into the genocide.

00:19:50: And somehow you know it felt like I had come in having to bear the brunt of myself killing children or something.

00:19:57: It was just unbearable.

00:19:59: Um...I think they were pretty lenient In the end..and i think The fact that we did manage to appeal the decision and get the decision dropped somehow shows that there is still a certain judicial independence within the German legal system,

00:20:20: but

00:20:21: it hasn't gone on like that for a lot of people.

00:20:23: I mean at the end of the day.

00:20:24: also It's very important to mention That i am christian!

00:20:29: I did come here as a curator I'm visibly queer

00:20:34: and...that

00:20:35: Is just not the case with alot of protesters.

00:20:39: people who've gone through the German legal system have gotten much, much heavier fines.

00:20:45: I think it plays an important role for judges to basically be able to imagine how much of a danger to society...I mean i don't speak german but through my habits and well integrated into Berlin Society somehow right?

00:20:59: It is not the case with everyone.

00:21:00: so..i was pretty lucky.

00:21:04: I want to ask you, there's a lot of sex in the book and i wanted to ask You about how you thought that sex sort-of worked politically.

00:21:13: Is There some relationship?

00:21:14: And also because we see even now after The left just won the election and saw this reaction In the press A lot was sexually motivated in Some way where the author was saying that he thought... The left-wing candidates in Neukern were acting because of a repressed desire for macho Arab men.

00:21:46: It really, there's this complicated sexual expression happening on the pages of Bill which is hard to work out!

00:21:55: I wondered why your book plays with these strange relationships between German paranoia, sex and politics.

00:22:03: And how did you find kind of working through all that?

00:22:06: I mean it's funny.

00:22:07: this the question of sex in a way manages to produce all these moral panics in German society is also something like the AfD is very good at deploying and mobilizing often contradictory ways.

00:22:18: That's something Dagmar Herzog speaks about nicely In another book published not so long ago.

00:22:25: This idea counties or amongst a certain electoral body, they'll represent the conservative family-friendly party.

00:22:33: And then in some others just use provocative sexual innuendos and whatnot.

00:22:43: I wanted to play around with this sexual politics of these tensions also because... To a sense it happened for me into people's past.

00:22:53: I find them quite funny, i think they reflect a repressed psyche amongst Germans.

00:22:59: that is interesting to work through.

00:23:00: I don't know what it's the name of necessarily nor am I seeking entirely pathologize it and its something you see alot also play out in gay clubs generally in Berlin.

00:23:14: You're always assumed as someone who will come into dominate a german man pull him into a certain direction in which he'll find himself, you know?

00:23:28: Subbing or just really like relinquishing to his desires.

00:23:33: Well I really liked the book in that every position that seemed sort of clear was then complicated.

00:23:41: in a way as you said In someway Ali seems to be at every remove.

00:23:48: He's an immigrant Arab queer And there are times in the book where it feels like incredibly sort of isolating, but another way.

00:23:57: you could say that he is a great model of different intersectional solidarities.

00:24:02: In that he does operate with The Street on The Streets Of Noika and sees people recognise his where they're from operates in these different communities.

00:24:10: so do think That There's just as much opportunity for solidarity in those crossing of identities?

00:24:19: I suppose

00:24:21: Yes and no because one thing that Ali believes, that I myself also believe.

00:24:29: And then i wanted to push the extreme through Ali's own experience was his apprehension towards all things intersectional which is also an apprehension that I my self have.

00:24:41: um...I am of the opinion there a time in place for everything even if it can be a bit doctrinaire.

00:24:51: I don't think, for example that in the aftermath of October seven or when we're mobilizing towards an ongoing genocide there is need to bring all these intersecting forms of oppression together.

00:25:02: To prove a point For example i've shared my own frustrations with this queers-for-palestine umbrella under which I think alot people tend want to bring certain respectability toward struggle.

00:25:15: That for me is respectable enough as it is Korea for Palestine, even though it greatly bothers Israel and its allies is something that bothers me too because I can see the logics behind wanting to counter pinkwashing.

00:25:36: And this in that on one hand but also do think within certain Western and activist contexts a lot of these things have been like blown out proportion given much space to negotiate rather than just you know built through and work with primarily the Palestinian diaspora towards, you know, proper anti-genocide politics.

00:26:01: Ali is a homosexual but he's not queer.

00:26:04: I wouldn't say the same for myself But if i made him so it's also because I'm not necessarily interested in the queer question in regards to this particular moment.

00:26:12: I think what interests me and Ali's sexuality is his ambivalent relationship towards, for example thinking of himself as a failure because somehow he is unable to be both fighting body and mind?

00:26:28: Because his homosexuality has somehow shielded him from the faith of people who were once his peers.

00:26:38: I think that to a certain extent, when you're Arab and queer.

00:26:43: You end up building certain cultural and sexual capital that shields from certain sense of responsibility may have back home And also it facilitates your navigation visa regimes.

00:26:57: This is why for example in court Ali brings this He's talking with his friend.

00:27:03: he says oh i thought would need come into court wearing the shirt have some gel in my hair and his friend advises him to actually come into clubwear because that is what would signal the German judge he's well assimilated.

00:27:19: And this is exactly how it happened with me.

00:27:20: aswell, This advice I was given to accentuate my queerness...

00:27:26: Because also isn't there something like if you sort of dress up a suit or whatever You look more like an immigrant?

00:27:34: Absolutely!

00:27:37: I mean, you know it's a problem with masculinity generally.

00:27:41: Who fears the Arab man

00:27:42: etc.,

00:27:42: etc.?

00:27:43: As you said Ali is an unreliable narrator but he living in this world is unreliables.

00:27:47: so everything sort of shifts that its hard to find solid ground anyway and i think that relates bit to what your saying Well wanted.

00:27:53: ask about one my favourite sections which comes quite late.

00:27:59: Which kind of fantasy of ali?

00:28:04: And he imagines the Berlin starts aerial bombing Neukölln.

00:28:10: And yeah, it's really funny.

00:28:12: could you describe that bit and then also tell us how you kind of came to this?

00:28:19: This was based on actually a night out during which a friend had a k-hole and started very genuinely panicking about the prospect And we were just having to calm him down, but I thought it was so indicative of certain fears and anxieties that people had.

00:28:39: It's a very exaggerated end... But still it really stuck with me!

00:28:45: Of course i have to draw out the comparison with Trayzdin which you know they're right-wing love also bring up in relation to Reza.

00:28:55: Also, not only did they find evidence the German state starts thinking to itself, how do we get all these muslims living here anyway?

00:29:09: And then they find tunnels that have been dug from the DDR into Neukölln as if in front of them kind snuck form east.

00:29:16: I like that extra layer of complication of this sort of German memory culture not only of the Holocaust but also the DDR and blending one with together was a really rich fantasy.

00:29:31: Do you think there's something They're in that kind of like?

00:29:34: how the kind of, how Neukern sort fits into German memory culture is in a strange way.

00:29:41: Or rather you could say how the muslim experience fits into german memory culture?

00:29:45: I mean i think neukernens are being quite an aberration for german memory cultural.

00:29:52: right.

00:29:56: it's here to... pull Germans into all directions like wondering what to do with it.

00:30:01: It becomes its problem space, um... Its major problemspace.

00:30:04: but I think that's quite interesting.

00:30:06: and bringing up this idea of the tunnels- The imaginary of the tunnel is something that is quite recurring in German right wing anxieties.

00:30:14: That was very prominent during the Holocaust.

00:30:21: Nazi officials were worried and that Jews would escape through tunnels, concentration camps.

00:30:28: In certain cases it did happen.

00:30:30: I mean the tunnel has always been you know the tunnel or underground railroad whatever.

00:30:34: there's always a rich history of fugitivity in struggle.

00:30:40: It is kind life affirming infrastructure which has populated a lot anti-colonial literature.

00:30:48: But it's also been a very present imaginary because of its potential to be invisible.

00:30:54: And so that's something, you know I mean would make someone go crazy.

00:30:58: Yeah

00:30:59: exactly and not to mention the tunnels in Gaza as another kind like place where I suppose, yeah.

00:31:07: Can you tell us a bit about how you came to the book and what other writers were you thinking of when you wrote it?

00:31:12: Because there are forms interesting too in this kind of tone here.

00:31:18: who was in... Who is he borrowing from or learning form as you write them?

00:31:21: Well first line on the books something that I borrowed from or rephrased from Krista Wolf City Of Angels.

00:31:33: At some point, she goes through all the stasi files that were kept on her and says every line I'm about to write is going be used against me.

00:31:41: So i wanted to play on it as well.

00:31:42: That's how I opened this book.

00:31:43: in a sense A major influence for me has always been Et al Adnan.

00:31:52: She was also quite an amazing writer too.

00:32:02: real-life character, a Christian woman who during the Civil War having attended to French Lissé with guys who end up becoming phalangists basically and she's a math teacher.

00:32:16: And she decides actually to join The Palestinian Resistance and she is kidnapped by her former classmates and then brutally executed.

00:32:31: working, wanting to work away out of death.

00:32:35: She has these conversations with her tormentors who used to be her classmates.

00:32:40: it's quite a poignant exploration of treason somehow and individual choice in the face of injustice.

00:32:47: At some point you say I think its when your talking about sort-of relationship to history also gentrification space Berlin and Beirut being from a sort of single ragged cloth or something.

00:33:02: What can you draw out that parallel bit?

00:33:04: How do you think about the two cities in relationship to each other?

00:33:07: well, In relation to particular things I mean there's also.

00:33:10: There's an obvious reference like both cities having been split into two for quite some time due to war-and conflict.

00:33:16: right yeah east beirut eastern west berlin but Also i mean it's in the small details Whatever we now consider to be spaces of leisure having had an extremely violent past In Beirut there's I mean our most famous club in Beirute, BO-Eighteen which was you know quite iconic in the nineties and is now reopened as well Was actually Built atop a mass grave of Palestinians And people tend to find that fact.

00:33:46: I don't know exhilarating.

00:33:47: um...and i think party culture in Beyrouth also built atop what was unsaid in regards to the civil war, which has never resolved.

00:33:58: It's always been a protracted conflict that somehow-to this day... ...has had no accountability process.

00:34:05: for I think you could draw quite easily into Berlin as well To the party culture that emanated from the nineties and Berlin This insouciance That also hides something far darker.

00:34:18: Everywhere we go in Berlin You end up realizing it is once a factory, which sorted things were happening or you know... A prison.

00:34:29: And it's quite similar in Beirut as well I mean when the city becomes playground for massacres You just cannot escape that each space inhabited like history of sheer depravity.

00:34:42: and yeah

00:34:44: Then finally i guess want to ask about politics sort of happening right now.

00:34:49: It seems like The sort of fever October seventh, and it's aftermath in Berlin the kind of political accusations And false accusations and reactions or whatever is somewhat back again after their election and that the extra victory of the left Do you feel like there's been any?

00:35:08: Kind of lifting up that fever.

00:35:10: Or do you think it still?

00:35:11: we're still kind of living through the same moment.

00:35:16: Yeah I think we're back in full force huh.

00:35:18: i mean i feel Like we've had a bit of uh A bit of a detente for awhile And now we're fully back on.

00:35:26: I feel like, for example what's been going with Delinke right now is very indicative of the two sort of religions or the liberal German state following reunification which there's Zionism doctrine but also anti-communism and seeing both these religions come into play to each other.

00:35:50: It's quite fascinating.

00:35:51: and how they both coalesce in wanting Delinca, making sure it doesn't ascend to power.

00:35:58: And all of the moral panics that came out of the Delinco victory in Berlin... I mean

00:36:03: yeah!

00:36:05: Okay so yeah, Firi Salih we recommend you go read this book on October twenty seventh.

00:36:11: Thank You very much Edwin Nasser.

00:36:12: Thanks for

00:36:14: listening another episode of The Heist Podcast.

00:36:17: We want say thanks again to Edwin Nasr And you can buy his book now.

00:36:21: It's called Fear Eats Ali, it came out just a few weeks ago hot off the press.

00:36:26: so check it out if you want and we'll be back with another episode of Heist in another two weeks.

00:36:30: In the meantime Check Out HeistBerlin.com for daily news features weekend guides and much more.

00:36:37: We will see ya soon Bye.

New comment

Your name or nickname, will be shown publicly
At least 10 characters long
By submitting your comment you agree that the content of the field "Name or nickname" will be stored and shown publicly next to your comment. Using your real name is optional.